Summary:
For this research point I;
– Drew on the work of Francesca Woodman, a portrait photographer who explored the human body and the idea of revealing and concealing.
– Stated my thoughts on her use of black and white photography, what it may represent and how it makes me feel.
– Reflected on the statements made by Victoria Miro and found examples of the points made within Woodman’s photography and how they enhanced the imagery.
– Briefly covered the effects that motion blur has on her work and the feelings they may create for the viewer, providing an example below to show traces of time.
– Drew on the work of Michael Wesley, a still life photographer who captures long exposures to document the invisible force that is time, showing traces of movement, light, life and decay.
– Reflect on how he captures what we may feel is impossible, by showing the universe around us by being patience and letting everything happen naturally instead of forcing it.
– Explored the work of Hiroshi Sugimoto, who also uses long exposure times to capture the entire length of a movie in a theatre, resulting in ghostly white screens illuminated a once full room.
– He too captures the ‘impossible’ by documenting the act of disappearance and showing what the camera saw over that period.
– Sugimoto challenges the idea of the moving image by turning what previously moved into a still image once more.
– Researched the work of Maarten Vanvolsem, a photographer who captures panoramas of people moving through a scene, documenting slices of time and showing a path of movement.
– Vanvolsem challenges the idea of time-based media which is usually film, audio or slides that show signs of movement over time. However he manages to present an audience with a path of movement in a single shot.
– Reflect on what I have found throughout this research and the impact of the visual/technical techniques used, as well as how they may encourage me to explore different approaches in the future.
Unlike fast shutter speeds that freeze movement as explored in the previous exercise, slower shutter speeds document activity and capture the path these motions leave behind.
Slow shutter speeds can create exciting results caused by unintentional camera shake, sudden movements or motion blur used intentionally as an art style like many artists explore throughout their work.
During this research, I would like to understand further why people use motion blur and capturing slices of time as an aesthetic choice and the impact this effect can have on the overall image.
Francesca Woodman (1958-1981)
Francesca Woodman was an American photographer who explored the human body by revealing, concealing and intentionally capturing the movement of herself or another female model, naked or otherwise.
The use of black and white photography not only adds to the ghostly eeriness depicted by the motion blur but may also be reflective of the artist’s mental state following her untimely death by suicide at the age of 22. Whether this was an intentional visual choice or not, it is impossible to ignore the raw emotion that radiates from her imagery.
‘Woodman tested the boundaries of bodily experience in her work and her work often suggests a sense of self-displacement. Often nude except for individual body parts covered with props, sometimes wearing vintage clothing, the artist is typically sited in empty or sparsely furnished, dilapidated rooms, characterised by rough surfaces, shattered mirrors and old furniture’ (Miro, 2014).
The use of empty rooms, with textural features, not only emphasises the importance of the body by creating a focus but also compliments the blurred movement or patterns on the vintage clothing worn, preventing the image from being flat and lifeless.
Victoria Miro states that Woodman’s exploration of presence and absence ‘argues for a kind of work that values disappearance as its very condition’ (Miro, 2014). Woodman deliberately prevents the viewer from seeing hidden areas even though they are, in fact, still there. Isolating parts of the body, through cropping, clothing or props; hints to what is missing, encouraging the viewer to think about the presence of the body and potentially question the choices made.
Distortion of the models features as is seen in Space² (see fig. 1.) not only preserves the identity of the subjects but implies the transition of one movement to another. It may also be a performance of an event that has previously taken place, due to Woodman’s ‘tendency to combine personalised psychodramas with the temporal and spatial displacements of long exposures and blurred movement’ (Badger, 2012).
Woodman’s use of motion blur, while not applied in every image, is intriguing and challenges the idea of what a still image can be by combining movement with still life.

Michael Wesely (1963- )
Michael Wesely is a contemporary photographer based in Berlin, who captures buildings, still life and portraits by using incredibly long exposures that can last for months or even years.
This approach allows the viewer to see movements that are too slow to be seen in real life, documenting what is invisible to the naked eye and the relationship between us and time itself by picturing the past and present. An prominent example of this is Stilleben (5.10-14.10.2011) (Wesley, 2011). The plate of figs that Wesely left for nine days are all perfectly plump until they begin to rot, split and collapse onto the surface as implied by the subtle yet powerful motion blur that captures this natural movement. The recording of decay may reflect on the idea that while time is infinite, time for us as humans is limited and should be cherished while we can experience it.
Instead of documenting movement that is sudden and visible, Wesely attempts to personify time which is something that we cannot physically see or some believe is but a concept. The form itself isn’t the only thing that matters anymore, as the ‘peripheral conditions such as light, movement, and other atmospheric elements’ (Wesely, n.d.) are just as necessary considering they all converge into one final image.
Wesely plays with the idea of movement and the traces of time, by letting the motions occur naturally instead of forcing it, by showing the growth or decay of a subject without influencing the outcome. To capture the universe around us seems impossible, as it exists, yet isn’t a physical object; however, Wesely has proven that you can indeed capture this information with patience.
Hiroshi Sugimoto (1948 – )
Hiroshi Sugimoto was born in Japan but has since travelled between Tokyo and New York after becoming a photographer in the ’70s, exploring the relationship between photography and time itself. Sugimoto’s practises consist of photography, architecture and performing arts production which investigates not only our short time on earth but also human knowledge based purely on senses and reality versus what could be (Fraenkel Gallery, 2012).
This approach is very much similar to Wesely, as Sugimoto too uses exceptionally long exposure times to capture traces of time that are invisible to the naked eye. An example of this features throughout his Theaters series (see fig. 2.) that began in 1976 and has spanned across the past four decades, ultimately capturing 130 individual movie theaters that illuminated by a bright white screen (McGrath, 2016).
Sugimoto opens the camera shutter as soon as the movie begins and only closes it once the credits roll, before developing the film to discover the most unusual yet fascinating results. You would imagine that photographing a moving image, would leave behind a distinct path of movement in its wake, however as shown, all that is left is an empty theater and a blank screen to light the room. While there was a full theater of people ‘…they all disappeared…the movie theater is the case to hold this emptiness…’ (Contacts : Hiroshi Sugimoto 2, 2009). So, Sugimoto managed to capture the impossible by encapsulating the disappearance with the empty shell of a building with no sign of life or movement besides the eerie light. The audience were there; they just cannot be seen, much like Woodman’s concept of isolating body parts, you cannot picture something disappearing if it wasn’t there in the first place.
Instead of using slow shutter speeds to capture a single motion to create blur or a double exposure effect, these long exposures have managed to combine multiple moving images into a single still once more. In turn, they are showing what the camera has seen over this period rather than what can physically be seen by the audience in real-time and documenting the invisible forces of time, through the use of light (Sugimoto, n.d.).
‘I wanted to photograph a movie, with all its appearance of life and motion, in order to stop it again… I must use photography as a means to shut away the ghosts resurrected by the excess of photographic afterimages’ (Sugimoto (n.d.) quoted in Musee Magazine, 2016).

Maarten Vanvolsem (1948 – )
Unlike the previous artists, Maarten Vanvolsem uses a moving camera to capture single slices of time to build up a still image across a short interval, to show traces of movement that challenge the perception of time and space. As a result, rather than shooting a single image and freezing a moment in time, Vanvolsem records multiple movements as the shutter is open by combining multiple seconds into one image.
Vanvolsem is the author of The Art Strip Photography an exploration of over 30 different artists approach to the strip technique and how the idea of time-based media may be possible for photography (Book Depository, n.d.).
Time-based media usually consists of film, audio, slides that can be watched and admired by the viewer over time to see what unfolds, while time isn’t explicitly visual, we as the audience are aware that moments are passing by the second (Tate, 2008). If you apply this logic to photography, we usually see frozen moments that are captured within milliseconds and therefore do not see time unfolding like a film. However, by using slow shutter speeds or in this case, a moving camera, time and movement can be documented in individual slices or exposures across a period. It may be a single image when produced, but time itself features in the frozen image through the multiple viewpoints and motions seen by the camera.
Instead of a strip made of individual frozen images like Muybridge’s work, Vanvolsem keeps his shutter open and pans the camera; as you would in panorama mode, to capture the events that take place during the time the shutter is open. Due to a slight movement in the camera or subject, visual distortion can occur, bending the composition and recording the small intricacies of activity that may not always be obvious in real-time.
35 x 90 cm (Vanvolsem, 2015) shows visual distortion, created by the dipping and rising of the subject in the frame, forming a wave of colour and smudge-like effect as they move across the frame. This result tells a story like a filmstrip would as we can distinguish what actions took place over this time, by looking at the trail that was left behind. 30 x 109 cm (Vanvolsem, 2015), however, suggests that the camera wasn’t always steady vertically due to the ripples in the architecture and ceiling which may imply an ‘up and down’ motion, although this isn’t confirmed.
Some people may not find this technique appealing as the images aren’t crisp and easy to dissect, however, is an incredible way to capture time and space in-camera while leaving a trace of movement in its path.
Reflection
Out of all the artists studied, the most appealing technical approaches for me were Woodman’s and Wesely’s, mainly for the ghostly results they managed to capture in their work. While Woodman may have had more control over the actions that occurred in her work, Wesely did not, instead, let nature take it’s course over a series of months to see what changed.
Motion blur brings life to the composition and provides more context as to what may be happening, what the subject is doing and at what pace or in what direction. Long exposures document change and decay that are not visible in real life, or at least it is less evident to us as humans.
Being able to confront how we see time and space, as well as capturing the impossible that is the act of disappearance by isolating features, blurring or showing what was left behind to imply emptiness, really does challenge what the ‘still’ image can be. A frozen moment shows but a slither of what is happening, leaving a trace behind gives more information for the viewer to explore and question.
References
Badger, G. (2012) ‘Gerry Badger >> Francesca Woodman’ [online] Available at : http://www.gerrybadger.com/francesca-woodman/ (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Book Depository. (n.d.) ‘The Art of Strip Photography : Maarten Vanvolsem’ [online] Available at : https://www.bookdepository.com/Art-Strip-Photography-Maarten-Vanvolsem/9789058678409 (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Contacts : Hiroshi Sugimoto 2 (2009) [online video] Available at : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rY3nGoZqw9U (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Fraenkel Gallery. (2012) ‘Hiroshi Sugimoto | Fraenkel Gallery’ [online] Available at : https://fraenkelgallery.com/artists/hiroshi-sugimoto (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Korff Fine Art (2018) ‘Michael Wesely’ [online] Available at: https://www.korff-stiftung.de/en/artworks/wesely-michael/editionen/stilleben-510-14102011 (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Kusseneers Gallery. (2015) ‘VANVOLSEM-4_30x19cm.jpg’ [image] Available at : http://kusseneerscom.webhosting.be/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/VANVOLSEM-4_30x109cm.jpg (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Kusseneers Gallery. (2015) ‘VANVOLSEM-5_32x90cm-12.jpg’ [image] Available at : http://kusseneerscom.webhosting.be/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/VANVOLSEM-5_32x90cm-12.jpg (Accessed 18 March 2020).
McGrath, E. (2016) ‘REVIEW: Theaters by Hiroshi Sugimoto – Musée Magazine’ [online] Available at : https://museemagazine.com/culture/2016/9/27/review-theaters-by-hiroshi-sugimoto (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Miro, V. (2014) ‘Francesca Woodman | Victoria Miro’ [online] Available at : https://www.victoria-miro.com/artists/7-francesca-woodman/ (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Sugimoto, H. (n.d.) ‘REVIEW: Theaters by Hiroshi Sugimoto – Musée Magazine’ [online] Available at : https://museemagazine.com/culture/2016/9/27/review-theaters-by-hiroshi-sugimoto (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Sugimoto, H. (n.d.) ‘Hiroshi Sugimoto | Fraenkel Gallery’ [online] Available at :https://fraenkelgallery.com/artists/hiroshi-sugimoto (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Tate. (2008) ‘Time-based media – Art Term | Tate’ [online] Available at : https://www.tate.org.uk/art/art-terms/t/time-based-media (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Wesely, M. (n.d.) on artnet (2009) ‘Michael Wesely | artnet’ [online] Available at : http://www.artnet.com/artists/michael-wesely/ (Accessed 18 March 2020).
List of images
Figure 1. Woodman, F. (1976) Space² [image] Available at : https://www.tate.org.uk/art/artworks/woodman-space-providence-rhode-island-ar00350 (Accessed 18 March 2020).
Figure 2. Sugimoto, H. (1993) Carpenter Center [image] Available at : https://www.sugimotohiroshi.com/new-page-7 (Accessed 18 March 2020).



















































